# Xu Ben Book-Article Overlap Table

Generated: 2026-06-17

This table shows which platform articles match book chapter titles. `book_relation_type` is a heuristic based on date comparison; close reading is needed for uncertain and recent cases.

## Summary

| Book | Year | Type | Chapters | Matches | Rate |
|---|---:|---|---:|---:|---:|
| 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 | 2015 | essay_collection | 80 | 37 | 46% |
| 明亮的对话：公共说理十八讲 | 2014 | systematic_monograph | 19 | 1 | 5% |
| 人以什么理由来记忆 | 2008 | essay_collection | 17 | 11 | 65% |
| 政治是每个人的副业 | 2013 | essay_collection | 9 | 8 | 89% |

| Relation type | Count |
|---|---:|
| article_before_book_recent | 39 |
| uncertain | 12 |
| article_before_book | 3 |
| book_excerpt_or_adaptation | 3 |

| Platform | Count |
|---|---:|
| Caixin only | 32 |
| Aisixiang only | 12 |
| Both | 13 |

## 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)

| Chapter | Article date | Platforms | Year diff | Relation type |
|---|---|---|---:|---|
| 雾霾里的乐观和犬儒 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 公共说理要避免动机指责 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 当今中国情非得已的在商言商 | 2013-08-05 | aisixiang+caixin | 2 | article_before_book |
| 豪宅和女色的阔文化 | 2013-11-10 | caixin | 2 | article_before_book |
| 为什么在中国要选择低危职业 | 2013-11-27 | caixin | 2 | article_before_book |
| 慈善并非都是善事 | 2014-01-27 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 信任是一种个人幸福的指标 | 2014-02-03 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 变断言为说理 | 2014-02-11 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 铁哥们的腐败 | 2014-03-02 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 冯小刚为什么厌烦电影 | 2014-03-04 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 恐怖袭击是涂抹道德色彩的恶 | 2014-03-24 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 红线可不可以划高一点 | 2014-03-31 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 你懂的是中国特色的犬儒主义 | 2014-04-06 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 整容的政治与伦理 | 2014-04-12 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 慰安妇塑像的法律与人道之争 | 2014-04-21 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 好社会需要自由的社团良心 | 2014-04-24 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 何必忧虑北大办成哈佛第二 | 2014-05-06 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 不作死就不会死是怎样的真理 | 2014-05-11 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 忧郁之外的自杀原因 | 2014-05-17 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 保护和慎用匿名的权利 | 2014-06-21 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 陈光标高调慈善是炫耀性消费 | 2014-07-03 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 恶心食品的法规与伦理 | 2014-07-15 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 犬儒时代的良心与希望 | 2014-07-16 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 涉色腐败为何令人恶心 | 2014-08-14 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 冰桶挑战与社会活动实践伦理 | 2014-08-25 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 以无聊的方式打发无聊的人生 | 2014-08-29 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 淫棍太多的争论 | 2014-09-02 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 交谈对话中的打断 | 2014-09-05 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 断章取义和撒谎 | 2014-09-17 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 我看见大象了 | 2014-10-18 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 当今中国社会的颓废与犬儒 | 2014-11-02 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 犬儒时代的年轻贪官 | 2014-11-10 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 思想改造的实录与思考 | 2014-11-16 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 为人治辩护为什么理亏 | 2014-12-19 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 什么是反腐的大快人心 | 2015-02-27 | caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |
| 中国的人情腐败 | 2015-03-24 | caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |
| 犬儒社会文化的困境与出路 | 2015-08-24 | aisixiang+caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |

## 人以什么理由来记忆 (2008)

| Chapter | Article date | Platforms | Year diff | Relation type |
|---|---|---|---:|---|
| 以骄傲的反抗积极生活 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 往事和争议 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 抗恶的防线 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 公共视野中的革命和政治自由 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 站在极权道德废墟上的雅斯贝尔斯 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 干净的手和肮脏的手 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 个人良知和公共政治 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 记忆窃贼和见证叙事的公共意义 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 卡兹纳与艾希曼 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 悲剧想象和公共政治 | 2011-12-19 | aisixiang+caixin | -3 | book_excerpt_or_adaptation |
| 人以什么理由来记忆 | 2016-02-15 | aisixiang+caixin | -8 | book_excerpt_or_adaptation |

## 政治是每个人的副业 (2013)

| Chapter | Article date | Platforms | Year diff | Relation type |
|---|---|---|---:|---|
| 公民教养 | ? | aisixiang | ? | uncertain |
| 集体记忆 | 2012-03-06 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 民众对政府的行政保密 | 2012-08-13 | aisixiang+caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |
| 政府有权管理个人嗜好 | 2013-01-02 | caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |
| 选民对政客的审慎信任 | 2013-04-12 | aisixiang+caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |
| 政治是每个人的副业 | 2013-05-18 | caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |
| 政治是一种怎样的公民副业 | 2013-06-07 | caixin | 0 | article_before_book_recent |
| 信任是一种个人幸福 | 2014-02-03 | caixin | -1 | book_excerpt_or_adaptation |

## 明亮的对话：公共说理十八讲 (2014)

| Chapter | Article date | Platforms | Year diff | Relation type |
|---|---|---|---:|---|
| 中国需要公共说理教育和公民理性 | 2013-12-23 | caixin | 1 | article_before_book_recent |

## Close Reading Priorities

The following cases need human verification of relation type:

### article_before_book_recent (0-1 year gap)

These could be:
- Platform article written as part of the book project, published online first
- Book chapter adapted for platform after manuscript completion but before publication
- Same-project simultaneous output from lectures/courses

- **犬儒社会文化的困境与出路** (2015-08-24, aisixiang+caixin) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)
- **犬儒时代的良心与希望** (2014-07-16, caixin) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)
- **铁哥们的腐败** (2014-03-02, caixin) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)
- **恐怖袭击是涂抹道德色彩的恶** (2014-03-24, caixin) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)
- **涉色腐败为何令人恶心** (2014-08-14, aisixiang+caixin) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)

### uncertain (no article date)

- **雾霾里的乐观和犬儒** (date unknown, aisixiang) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)
- **公共说理要避免动机指责** (date unknown, aisixiang) → 颓废与沉默：透视犬儒文化 (2015)
- **以骄傲的反抗积极生活** (date unknown, aisixiang) → 人以什么理由来记忆 (2008)
- **往事和争议** (date unknown, aisixiang) → 人以什么理由来记忆 (2008)
- **抗恶的防线** (date unknown, aisixiang) → 人以什么理由来记忆 (2008)